Back in September I made a post announcing the release of the Cannon G12 point and Shoot camera. I did this primarily because I get asked a lot to recommend cameras to my workshop students and friends. As far as point and shoot cameras go I think think the Cannon G series is hard to beat. But there are some other professional level point and shoot cameras that are in the same price range and are very much worth considering.
B&H Photo and Video put together a great comparison of these professional point and shoot cameras. I thought it might be nice to pass this information on to you, so with the permission of Issaic at B&H I have copied their article below. It includes a short video that hits the highlights in case you don’t want to read all the way through. At the bottom there is also a comparison chart.
Each of the following cameras is unique in that it incorporates the sort of features serious shooters prefer even in their “down-time” cameras. These features include fast apertures, high-quality glass, sturdier-than-average construction, full manual override, JPEG+RAW still capture, a hotshoe for use with flashguns and accessories, analog-style controls for quick and intuitive on-the-fly exposure adjustments and a tactile feel that makes you want to take one wherever you go.
Five out of six of these cameras contain 10MP imaging sensors typical of their class. The exception is the Leica X1, which contains a larger APS-C sensor despite it’s easily pocketable size. As for optics, each of these cameras features premium glass with wide maximum apertures, the slowest among them f2.8 and the fastest a truely bright f/1.8.
Two of the cameras, the Canon PowerShot G12 and Nikon CoolPix P7000, feature optical viewfinders coupled to their respective zoom lenses as welcome (though peephole-ish) alternatives to composing and editing images on the camera’s LCD under bright lighting conditions. Similarly, you can slip optical finders (DMV-VF1) onto the hotshoes of the Panasonic Lumix DMC-LX5 and Leica D-LUX 5 that match the wide-angle field of view of the 24-90mm equivalent Leica DC Vario-Summicron lens that is shared by both cameras. Leica also offers a hotshoe-mounted optical finder matched to the angle of view of the camera’s fixed lens (Leica X1 Brightline Finder).
Canon
The Canon PowerShot G12 is the latest in a long line of top shelf pro point-and-shoot cameras. Encased in a tough, all-metal housing, the G12 features a DIGIC 4-powered 10 MP CCD, an image-stabilized 5x (28-140mm equivalent) UA zoom lens, full manual override, close focusing down to 0.4″ from the lens surface and a 2.8″ (460,000-dot) Vari-Angle LCD.
In the imaging department the PowerShot G12 can capture JPEGs, RAW, JPEG+RAW, as well as 720p HD video with sound. The top shutter speed of the G12 is 1/4000th-second and you can squeeze off up to two frames per second when shooting flat out. In the power department, you can expect up to 1000 exposures-per-charge and for recording stills and video, the G12 accepts SD, SDHC, SDXC, MMC, MMC Plus, HC MMC Plus memory cards.
Nikon
Similar in design is Nikon’s CoolPix P7000, which in addition to a 10.1 MP CCD, a coupled optical finder, JPEG and/or RAW still capture, analog style control dials and a 3″ (921,000-dot) LCD, can also capture 720p HD video with stereo sound. The lens, a five-way optically stabilized 28-200mm equivalent zoom with a maximum aperture of f/2.8 and close focusing down to 0.8″ from the lens surface, has the widest focal range in its class.
Along with all of the above, a new EXPEED C2 imaging processor keeps things moving at burst rates up to 1.3 frames per second continuous shooting for up to 45 frames. Other important features found on the CoolPix P7000 include Active D- Lighting, a top shutter speed of 1/4000th-second and top ISO sensitivity of 12,800. The P7000 accepts SD, SDHC and SDXC memory cards, and for times you find yourself in dire straights, the P7000 contains about 79MB of internal memory. As for shooting times, according to Nikon, you can expect to squeeze off about 350 stills or two hours and 45 minutes of HD video per battery charge.
Samsung
Mention the name Samsung and most people think HDTVs, remote controls and cell phones, but as theSamsung TL500 illustrates, Samsung’s engineers seem to take low-light shooting with sturdy pocket cameras seriously. Among its key attributes is a 10MP CCD, a fully-rotatable 3″ AMPLOD display, dual image stabilization systems, a hotshoe, analog-style control dials, JPEG and/or RAW, in-camera RAW processing, full manual overrride and MPEG-4 AVC/H.264 video with stereo sound.
The biggest selling point of the Samsung TL500 has to be its Schneider 3x, 24-72mm equivalent wide-angle zoom, which with a maximum aperture of f/1.8 is a third-stop faster than its closest f/2 competitors. Even at the 72mm mark, the lens still transmits a respectable maximum aperture of f/2.4.
The TL500’s f/1.8 maximum aperture also allows for a wee bit more selective focus when shooting tight, narrow-focus images, which in the world of tiny imaging sensors, isn’t all that easy. The Samsung TL500 accepts SD and SDHC memory cards and contains a rather hefty 1GB of internal memory.
Panasonic
Panasonic’s Lumix DMC-LX5 is a trim, smartly-designed pocket camera that features an f/2, Leica DC Vario-Summicron Aspheric zoom lens with a 24-90mm equivalent zoom range, that along with a top ISO setting of 12,800, makes it an ideal pocket-sized street-shooting machine. To complement the camera’s 3″ 460,000-dot LCD, the Lumix LX5 allows you the option of slipping a 24mm FOV DMV-VF1 optical finder (optional ) onto the LX5’s hotshoe for fast and accurate, eye-to-the-ocular shooting.
Like the other cameras in the pro-quality point-and-shoot category, the Panasonic Lumix DMC-LX5 features a hotshoe and captures stills in the form of JPEG and/or RAW. Other features include a top shutter speed of 1/4000th-second, up to 2.5 frames per second continuous shooting, macro focusing down to 0.39″ (1cm) from the front lens surface, and 720p @ 30 fps HD video capture. The Lumix LX5 accepts SD, SDHC or SDXC memory cards and contains about 40MB of internal memory.
Leica
From Leica we have not one but two distinct and unique models to choose from, starting with the Leica X1, which despite its compact profile contains a 12.2MP APS-C format CMOS sensor, similar in size and resolving power to the sensors found in compact DSLRs. To complement the camera’s hi-res sensor, the X-1 has a super-sharp, 24mm f/2.8 Leica Elmarit fixed focal length lens that renders the field of view of a 36mm lens on a full-frame Leica M-series camera, which as you might have guessed, was part of the master plan.
12.2MP APS-C Format Sensor and is available in Black or Silver.
Manufactured entirely in Germany and available in a choice of Blackor Silver, the Leica is strictly a still camera, and like it’s larger sibling there’s no video capture with this baby. Out of the box, the X-1 features a 2.7″ LCD for composing and editing imagery, but to better facilitate the full Leica experience, the Leica X1 Brightline Finder, designed to match the 62° angle-of-view of the camera’s lens, is highly recommended. There’s also an optional X1 Handgrip, which screws onto the base of the camera to add a positive handhold when grasping the camera.
Other features found on the Leica X-1 include JPEG and/or RAW (DNG) capture, analog controls with full manual overrides, Live View, 11 AF points, a two-year international warranty and a copy of Adobe Lightroom 3, which is downloadable when you register your camera online.
Our second offering from Leica is the Leica D-LUX 5, which (truth be told) is one and the same as the Panasonic Lumix DMC-LX5 described above once you dig down under the skin. The skin it’s been replaced with, however, is pretty sleek and features the ego-satisfying red Leica logo.
As for image quality, the firmware in the Leica D-LUX5 is designed to render color and tone more neutrally than its Panasonic counterpart, which like most cameras from Japanese manufacturers, renders color and tone at punchier levels.
Along with an f/2, Leica DC Vario-Summicron Aspheric zoom lens (24-90mm equivalent), the Leica D-LUX5 features a top ISO setting of 12,800, 3″ 460,000-dot LCD (and optional DMV-VF1 optical finder), JPEG and/or RAW still capture, a top shutter speed of 1/4000th-second, up to 2.5 frames-per-second continuous shooting, macro focusing down to 0.39″ (1cm) and 720p @ 30 f-p-s HD video capture. The Lumix LX5 accepts SD, SDHC, or SDXC memory cards and contains about 40MB of internal memory. The Leica D-LUX5 comes with a two-year international warranty, which is twice up from the industry standard of one year.
Sensor | Lens | Image Viewing | Stills | Video | Highest ISO Rating | |
Nikon CoolPix P7000 | 10.1Mp CCD (1/1.7″) | 28-200mm/f2.8-5.6 (Equivalent) | 3″ LCD(921,000-dots) Coupled Optical Finder (80% Coverage) |
JPEG
+RAW |
720p
@30fps |
ISO 12,800 |
Canon PowerShot G12 | 10Mp CCD (1/1.7″) |
28-140mm/f2.8-4.5 (Equivalent) | Vari-Angle 2.8″ LCD (460,000-dots) Coupled Optical Finder (approx 80% coverage) |
JPEG
+RAW |
720p
@24fps |
ISO 3200 |
Samsung TL500 | 10Mp CCD (1/1.7″) |
24-72mm/f1.8-2.4 (Equivalent) | 3″ OLED (614,000-dots) | JPEG
+RAW |
MPEG-4 AVC
/H.264 (Mono Sound) |
ISO 3200 |
Panasonic Lumix DMC-LX5 | 10.1Mp CCD (1/1.6″) | 24-90mm/f2-3.3 (Equivalent) | 3″ LCD(460,000-dots) | JPEG
+RAW |
720p
@24fps |
ISO 12,800 |
Leica D-LUX 5 | 10.1Mp CCD (1/1.63″) | 24-90mm/f2-3.3 (Equivalent) | 3″ LCD(460,000-dots) | JPEG
+RAW |
720p
@30fps |
ISO 12,800 |
Leica X1 | 12.2Mp CMOS (APS-C) | 24mm/f2.8 (Fixed 36mm Equiv) | 2.7″ LCD (230,000-dots) | JPEG
+RAW |
None | ISO 3200 |
Leave a Reply